Frequently Asked Questions
What is considered burglary under New York law?
In New York, burglary means entering or remaining unlawfully in a building with the intent to commit a crime inside. It does not require stealing anything—intent alone can be enough.
What degree of burglary am I charged with?
Burglary can be charged as third, second, or first degree, depending on factors like whether the building was a home, whether anyone was present, or whether a weapon was involved.
Is burglary a felony in New York?
Yes. All burglary charges in New York are felonies, though the severity and potential punishment vary by degree.
What’s the difference between burglary and criminal trespass?
Trespass means being somewhere unlawfully. Burglary requires intent to commit another crime inside, which is what makes it more serious.
Do I have to steal something to be guilty of burglary?
No. You can be charged with burglary even if nothing was taken, as long as prosecutors claim you intended to commit a crime inside.
What are the possible penalties for burglary in New York?
Penalties range from probation to lengthy prison sentences, depending on the degree charged, your criminal history, and the facts of the case.
What if I didn’t intend to commit a crime?
Intent is a key element. If the prosecution cannot prove intent beyond a reasonable doubt, the case may be reduced or dismissed.
Can burglary charges be reduced to a lesser offense?
Yes. Depending on the circumstances, charges may be reduced to attempted burglary, trespass, or another non-felony offense.
What should I do immediately after being charged?
Do not discuss the case with anyone except your lawyer. Contact a criminal defense attorney immediately and follow their advice closely.
How can a criminal defense lawyer help me?
A lawyer protects your rights, challenges the evidence, negotiates with prosecutors, and fights for the best possible outcome—whether that’s dismissal, reduction, or trial defense.
Schedule A Consultation
Burglary Charges Can Be Challenged By A New York Criminal Defense Lawyer
In New York City more than 12,000 people are charged with burglary every year! Being accused of burglary in New York is a serious criminal charge. An arrest often happens suddenly and often involves aggressive police tactics. Burglary arrests expose you to felony charges even if no violence occurrs.
Prosecutors treat burglary as a crime of intent, meaning the focus is not only on what happened, but what they claim you planned to do. Our experienced New York criminal defense lawyer will step in early to protect your rights and fight back before your case spirals out of control.
What Is Burglary Under New York Law
Under New York Penal Law, burglary is not simply breaking into a building. You may be charged with burglary if you knowingly enter or remain unlawfully in a building with the intent to commit a crime inside. The alleged intent of a crime does not require theft and could involve any criminal act. This broad definition allows police and prosecutors wide discretion in making arrests and prosecuting burglary charges.
Burglary charges often arise from misunderstandings, disputes, or weak assumptions about intent. You may believe you had permission to be on the property, or that you never intended to commit a crime at all. Despite this, law enforcement will often pursue felony charges. A skilled defense lawyer from the Law Offices of Michael S. Discioarro can challenge whether the legal elements of burglary were actually met.
Why Intent Is the Key Issue in Burglary Cases
Unlike theft or assault, burglary centers on intent at the moment of entry or remaining. Prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you intended to commit a crime. Intent is often inferred rather than proven directly. This creates significant opportunities for our experienced legal team to bolster your defense strategy.
Our criminal defense lawyers will challenge whether intent existed at all. Innocent explanations, lack of evidence, and inconsistent witness statements that undermine the prosecution’s theory. Without proof of intent, a burglary charge will not stand.
Degrees of Burglary in New York
New York recognizes several degrees of burglary, each with different penalties. Burglary in the third degree involves unlawfully entering or remaining in a building with criminal intent and is a class D felony. Burglary in the second degree applies when the alleged burglary involves a dwelling, or when certain aggravating factors are present, and is a class C felony. Burglary in the first degree is the most serious, involving a dwelling plus aggravating factors such as injury, a weapon, or the presence of another person, and is a class B felony.
The degree charged has a major impact on potential prison exposure and long term consequences. Prosecutors often overcharge burglary cases to gain leverage. Early legal intervention can reduce the degree or result in dismissal.
Why You May Be Arrested for Burglary
Burglary arrests in New York frequently occur without clear physical evidence. Police rely on circumstantial facts such as time of day, location, or prior history. Being found inside or near a building can be enough for officers to assume unlawful entry. Statements made during questioning are often used to support claims of criminal intent.
Disputes between landlords and tenants, domestic conflicts, and commercial disagreements also lead to burglary charges. In many cases, the accused believed they had the right to enter the property. Police may still arrest first and leave the details for later. Our criminal defense lawyers can investigate whether the arrest was legally justified and followed proper procedure.
Penalties for Burglary in New York
Burglary is always treated as a felony in New York. Even the lowest degree exposes a defendant to significant prison time. A class D felony burglary conviction can result in up to seven years in state prison. Higher degree burglary charges can lead to decades in jail.
Beyond prison, a burglary conviction carries lifelong consequences. A felony conviction will affect employment, housing, licenses, and immigration status. Probation, post release supervision, fines, and restitution are also imposed. The impact of a criminal burglary conviction extends far beyond the courtroom.
Sentencing Factors in Burglary Cases
Judges consider many factors when sentencing, including prior criminal history and alleged aggravating conduct. Prosecutors may argue for enhanced penalties based on weapons, injury, or the presence of occupants. Even allegations that are never proven at trial can influence plea negotiations. A strong defense strategy from our legal experts will counter most narratives.
An early defense may also prevent prosecutors from adding or upgrading charges. Once a case progresses, leverage often shifts to the state. Acting quickly to consult with legal counsel usually makes a meaningful difference in the outcome of burglary cases.
The Importance of Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer Early
The earliest stages of a burglary case are the most critical. Police reports, witness statements, and surveillance evidence are created immediately after arrest. Errors made during this phase shape the entire case. Retaining an experience criminal defense attorney early helps prevent procedural violations from going unchallenged.
Our defense attorney communicates directly with law enforcement and prosecutors on your behalf. This reduces the risk of damaging statements and improper evidence collection. Early advocacy often influences charging decisions before they become final.
Challenging Police Procedure and Evidence
Burglary cases frequently involve questionable searches and seizures. Police may enter homes, vehicles, or phones without proper legal authority. Evidence obtained in violation of constitutional rights may be suppressed. Suppression can weaken or destroy the prosecution’s case.
Our defense lawyers also analyze whether the arrest itself was lawful. Lack of probable cause can lead to dismissal. Chain of custody issues, flawed forensic analysis, and unreliable surveillance footage are all areas that require careful review.
We Protect Your Rights During an Investigation
Many people unknowingly waive their rights during burglary investigations. Statements made to police, even informal ones, are often used as evidence of intent. A lawyer ensures that your rights are asserted and protected at every stage. Silence and legal guidance are powerful tools.
Your attorney can also conduct an independent investigation. This may include locating witnesses, obtaining records, and preserving evidence that supports your defense. Waiting to consult with our defense lawyers often results in lost opportunities.
We Will Build a Strong Burglary Defense
Every burglary case is unique and requires a strategy that is tailored to your unique circumstances. Some defenses will focus on lawful entry, while others may challenge intent or identity. In most cases our goal is dismissal of criminal charges. In others, it is charge reduction or a non felony resolution.
An experienced New York criminal defense lawyer understands how local courts and prosecutors handle burglary cases. This insight allows for strategic negotiation and aggressive litigation when necessary. Preparation and early action often separate successful defenses from devastating outcomes.
Consult With a New York Burglary Defense Lawyer Today
If you are facing a burglary charge in New York, time is not on your side. The decisions made in the first days and weeks can define the rest of your life. You deserve a defense that challenges assumptions, exposes weaknesses, and protects your future. Contact an experienced New York criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible to begin building your defense and safeguarding your rights.
Call the law offices of Michael S. Disciarro today, 917-519-8417
