Frequently Asked Questions
What is considered assault?
Assault occurs when a person intentionally, recklessly, or negligently causes physical injury or threatens immediate physical harm to another person.
What is the difference between assault and battery?
In New York, assault focuses on causing or attempting to cause injury, while battery generally refers to actual physical contact.
Can threats alone be considered assault?
Yes. Intentionally placing someone in fear of imminent physical harm can qualify as assault under New York Penal Law.
What should I do if I am arrested for assault?
Do not speak to police without a lawyer. Early legal representation is critical to protect your rights.
Can assault charges arise from a fight where I acted in self-defense?
Possibly. Police often arrest all parties involved. A lawyer can assert self-defense if you were protecting yourself.
Can assault charges be reduced or dismissed?
Often. Charges may be reduced to harassment or disorderly conduct depending on evidence and circumstances.
What are the penalties for assault convictions?
Penalties vary by degree, ranging from fines and probation for misdemeanors to years in prison for felonies.
Can assault convictions result in probation?
Yes. Lower-degree assaults or first-time offenses may be eligible for probation, community service, or anger management programs.
How do I choose the right assault defense lawyer?
Look for trial experience, knowledge of New York assault laws, strong negotiation skills, and a lawyer who communicates clearly and aggressively defends your rights.
Schedule A Consultation
New York City Assault Defense Lawyer
Being accused of assault in New York City is a serious matter with potentially life-altering consequences. Assault charges are aggressively prosecuted by the NYPD and district attorneys, often with little regard for the surrounding circumstances or valid defenses such as self-defense. Each year, thousands of people are arrested and prosecuted for assault in New York City, many of whom should never have been charged in the first place.
Violent crime allegations carry higher stakes than almost any other criminal charge. Judges and juries tend to view assault cases harshly, particularly when injuries are involved. If you are facing an assault charge, it is critical to work with an experienced New York City assault defense lawyer who understands how these cases are investigated, charged, and tried.
Understanding Assault Charges in New York
Under New York Penal Law, assault is defined broadly and includes a wide range of conduct. Assault charges can arise from street altercations, domestic disputes, bar fights, workplace incidents, or misunderstandings that escalate quickly. What may begin as a verbal argument can result in an arrest within minutes once police are called.
Contrary to popular belief, an assault charge does not require a weapon or severe injury. Even relatively minor physical contact can result in criminal charges, depending on how law enforcement and prosecutors interpret the incident.
Types of Assault Under New York Law
Simple Assault (Misdemeanor Assault)
A fistfight or physical altercation without weapons is often charged as a misdemeanor assault, typically Assault in the Third Degree under Penal Law §120.00. These cases often involve allegations of intentional or reckless injury and can still carry serious penalties, including jail time, probation, and a permanent criminal record.
Felony Assault
More serious allegations may result in felony assault charges. Felony assault cases usually involve:
- Use of a deadly weapon or dangerous instrument
- Serious physical injury
- Assault on protected individuals such as police officers or transit employees
Assault With a Deadly Weapon is treated far more seriously than simple assault and exposes defendants to lengthy prison sentences.
Assault With Intent to Cause Serious Harm
New York law also recognizes assault charges involving intent to commit particularly serious acts, including Assault With Intent to Rape, Maim, or Murder. These allegations are aggressively prosecuted and often accompanied by high bail or remand without bail.
Penalties and Consequences for Assault Convictions
Assault convictions in New York carry severe penalties that increase dramatically depending on the degree of the charge.
Misdemeanor Assault Penalties
- Up to 364 days in jail
- Probation
- Fines and surcharges
- Anger management or counseling
- Permanent criminal record
Felony Assault Penalties
- State prison sentences ranging from several years to decades
- Mandatory post-release supervision
- High fines
- Loss of firearm rights
- Immigration consequences for non-citizens
Violent crimes are taken extremely seriously by the courts and frequently involve high bail amounts or no bail at all. The long-term consequences can affect employment, professional licenses, housing, and family relationships.
Why Assault Cases Are Often Wrongfully Prosecuted
Each year, thousands of people are wrongfully prosecuted for assault in New York City. Despite valid self-defense claims, the NYPD will usually arrest the perceived “winner” of a fight, even when the other person initiated the violence. Police officers often arrive after the incident has occurred and rely on incomplete or biased statements when making arrest decisions.
Judges and juries are often tough on assault cases because of the visible damage suffered by an alleged victim. Unfortunately, this focus can overshadow critical facts, such as who started the altercation or whether the accused was acting lawfully to protect themselves.
Assault Defenses That Can Make the Difference
Self-Defense
Self-defense is one of the most powerful and commonly misunderstood defenses in assault cases. New York law allows individuals to use reasonable force to protect themselves or others. Properly presenting a self-defense claim requires careful investigation and legal strategy.
Lack of Intent
Many assault charges hinge on intent. Accidental contact, misidentification, or exaggerated injuries can undermine the prosecution’s case when properly exposed.
False Allegations
Assault accusations frequently arise in emotionally charged situations, including domestic disputes and custody conflicts. These allegations must be aggressively scrutinized.
The Importance of Pre-Trial Investigation
One of the keys to a successful violent crime defense is thorough pre-trial investigation. Effective investigation can uncover prosecution missteps, identify exculpatory evidence, and expose weaknesses in the state’s case.
A strong defense often involves:
Reviewing surveillance footage
- Interviewing witnesses
- Examining medical records
- Utilizing DNA analysis
- Employing polygraph examinations when appropriate
The prosecution relies on experienced investigators whose sole job is to build a case against you. At the same time, many defendants are provided with overburdened public defenders who lack the resources necessary to fully investigate complex violent crime allegations.
A Trial-Ready Assault Defense Strategy
Defending against violent criminal charges requires preparation, resources, and a willingness to take cases to trial when necessary. We prepare every case as if it will be tried before a jury. We do not rush to plea your rights away.
Mounting a successful defense requires a defense team with experience fighting assault charges. Prosecutors typically will not pursue cases they do not believe they can prove at trial. That is why it is critical to dig deeper into the evidence than the prosecution and inject reasonable doubt at every stage of the case.
Experienced Representation Matters
Mr. Discioarro has handled hundreds of assault cases and understands how to effectively represent clients accused of violent crimes. His experience allows him to anticipate prosecution strategies, challenge flawed investigations, and pursue the best possible outcomes—whether through dismissal, reduction of charges, or trial verdicts.
When your freedom, reputation, and future are on the line, you need a New York City assault defense lawyer who knows how to fight back.
