Call 917-519-8417
Frequently Asked Questions
What is considered arson?
Arson involves intentionally damaging or destroying property by fire or explosion.
Are all arson cases felonies?
Most are felonies, but minor cases, such as burning debris on private property without risk to others, may be charged as misdemeanors.
Does arson include attempted fire-setting?
Yes. Attempted arson or reckless conduct that could have caused a fire may still result in criminal charges.
What should I do if I am arrested for arson?
Do not speak to police without a lawyer. Early legal representation is crucial.
Can I be charged for accidental fires?
Yes, if the fire resulted from reckless or negligent behavior. Intent is not required for some degrees of arson.
What are the penalties for arson convictions?
Penalties range from fines and probation for misdemeanors to decades in prison for first-degree arson.
Can I be charged if someone else set the fire but I was nearby?
Yes, under aiding and abetting or conspiracy laws if prosecutors claim you encouraged, assisted, or planned the act.
Schedule A Consultation
NYC Arson Defense Lawyer
Aggressive Defense for Arson Charges in New York
An arson arrest in New York City is a life-altering event. Prosecutors treat arson as a serious violent felony, even when no one is hurt and the damage is limited. A single accusation can expose you to years in state prison, steep fines, and a permanent criminal record.
If you or a loved one is facing arson charges, you need a New York criminal defense lawyer who understands the science, the law, and the aggressive tactics used by prosecutors. Arson cases are complex. They often rely on circumstantial evidence, questionable fire investigations, and assumptions about intent.
A strong defense can make the difference between dismissal, reduction, or devastating penalties.
Understanding Arson Under New York Penal Law
New York Penal Law defines arson across five degrees, ranging from a misdemeanor to a Class A-I felony. The severity depends on factors such as intent, property damage, risk of injury, and whether a building was occupied.
Each degree has its own legal elements that the prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt. If they fail to prove even one element, the charge can collapse.
An experienced arson defense attorney examines every detail.
NY Penal Law Section 150: Arson
Arson in the Fifth Degree – Penal Law § 150.01
Arson in the fifth degree is a Class A misdemeanor. It involves intentionally damaging property by fire or explosion.
No building needs to be involved. No person needs to be present. However, intent is still required.
Even though this is the lowest arson charge, the consequences are real.
A conviction can result in:
- Up to 364 days in jail
- Fines and restitution
- A permanent criminal record
Your criminal defense lawyer can challenge whether the fire was intentional, accidental, or caused by negligence rather than criminal conduct.
Arson in the Fourth Degree – Penal Law § 150.05
Fire With Reckless Disregard for Safety
Arson in the fourth degree is a Class E felony. It applies when a person intentionally starts a fire and recklessly places another person or a building at risk.
Actual injury is not required. Risk alone may be enough.
These cases often arise from:
- Fires in shared buildings
- Fires near occupied structures
- Allegations involving recklessness
A felony conviction can affect employment, housing, professional licenses, and immigration status.
Early legal intervention is critical.
Arson in the Third Degree – Penal Law § 150.10
Intentional Fire to a Building or Vehicle
Arson in the third degree is a Class C felony. It involves intentionally damaging a building or motor vehicle by fire or explosion.
Ownership does not matter. Even setting fire to your own property can result in felony charges.
Prosecutors frequently rely on:
- Fire marshal conclusions
- Accelerant detection
- Witness statements
- Surveillance footage
Defense strategies often include challenging fire origin analysis, contamination of evidence, or flawed expert testimony.
Arson in the Second Degree – Penal Law § 150.15
Serious Felony With Risk of Injury
Arson in the second degree is a Class B felony. This charge applies when a fire is set to a building and another person is present or reasonably believed to be present.
No one needs to be harmed. The presence or perceived presence is enough.
Penalties can include:
- Lengthy state prison sentences
- Mandatory post-release supervision
- Heavy fines
These cases demand immediate and aggressive defense, often involving independent fire experts and forensic review.
Arson in the First Degree – Penal Law § 150.20
Arson in the first degree is a Class A-I felony, the highest level under New York law. It applies when a person intentionally starts a fire and causes serious physical injury, using an incendiary device or accelerant.
This charge carries some of the harshest penalties in the entire Penal Law.
- A conviction may result in:
- Decades in prison
- Lifetime consequences
- No room for error in defense
These cases are aggressively prosecuted. They require a defense attorney with experience handling high-stakes felony litigation.
Common Defenses to Arson Charges
Arson cases are rarely straightforward. Fires destroy evidence, and investigators often form conclusions under pressure.
An experienced defense attorney can argue:
- The fire was accidental, not intentional
- The cause of the fire was misidentified
- Accelerant evidence was contaminated or misinterpreted
- Statements were coerced or unlawfully obtained
- The prosecution cannot prove intent
Every case is fact-specific. There is no one-size-fits-all defense.
Why Arson Cases Are Different
Unlike many crimes, arson cases rely heavily on expert opinions. Fire science is not exact, and outdated investigative techniques are still used.
Prosecutors may overcharge based on assumptions rather than proof.
An experienced arson defense lawyer understands how to:
- Cross-examine fire investigators
- Challenge expert conclusions
- Expose weaknesses in forensic evidence
- Protect your constitutional rights
The earlier that a criminal defense lawyer becomes involved, the stronger your defense can be.
New York City Arson Defense You Can Trust
If you are under investigation or have been arrested for arson in New York City, time matters. Statements, evidence, and charging decisions happen quickly.
Do not speak to law enforcement without legal counsel.
An experienced NYC criminal defense lawyer can intervene early, protect your rights, and fight for the best possible outcome – whether that means dismissal, reduction, or acquittal.
Your freedom, reputation, and future are worth defending.
Because arson is considered such a serious crime, if you or someone you know has been arrested for arson you should move quickly to retain a qualified criminal defense attorney that can assist with your defense. You are likely confused and anxious about what steps to take if you have been charged with this crime, and you will need good legal counsel to direct you in the proper path to take to protect your rights.
At The Law Offices of Michael S. Discioarro, LLC we have very knowledgeable criminal defense attorneys who will provide you with personal service. We will take the time to pull apart every aspect of the prosecutor’s case to determine what really happened and how best to defend your case. Contact us today for a confidential consultation.
Criminal Defense Testimonials
Areas Of Practice
Member Of
